Insane or Sane - 1414 Words

Is He Truly Insane? â€Å"The man denies that he is insane. He offers proof. Can you believe him?† (Poe, 22) This is one of the most intriguing lines in the short story ‘The Tell Tale Heart’ written by Edgar Allan Poe. This quote defines the whole purpose of the short story in fewer than two sentences. The whole story is dedicated to proving that the narrator in the short story is actually, sane. Due to many pieces of evidence, one can have various opinions in debating whether the narrator is insane or sane. For instance, the narrator in the story watched the old man sleep for countless days, cut up the corps of the old man and placed in under the boards, and claimed he heard the heartbeat of the old man once he was dead. Therefore it†¦show more content†¦The narrator acted calmly. â€Å"I took my visitors all over the house. I blade them search – search well. I led them, at length, to his chamber.† (Poe, 25) This quote from the story tells us that the narrator showed courage, giving the impression that he had ‘nothing’ to hide (whi ch he did). After the police officers started to believe the narrator, the narrator started to hear a sound. It was the heartbeat of the old man. He then spoke louder, so loud so that the police officers wouldn’t be able to hear the â€Å"sound.† â€Å"The ringing in my ears: but still they sat and still chatted. The ringing became more distinct- it continued and became more distinct; I talked more freely to get rid of the feeling; but it continued and gained definiteness- until, at length, I found that the noise was not within his ears.† (Poe, 26) This lets readers know that the sound of the old man’s heartbeat, the same heartbeat that he heard before he killed him, was getting louder and louder. â€Å"Was it possible they heard not? Almighty God! –no, no! They heard! - They suspected! - They knew! - They were making a mockery of my horror! - this I thought, and this I think.† (Poe, 26) This means that the narrator thought that the police o fficers were able to hear the heartbeat and were just mocking him, so that he would turn himself in. After a while theShow MoreRelatedSane Or Insane, Insane928 Words   |  4 PagesSane or Insane It was said in the 1970 s most Psychiatric professionals predicted their own beliefs while diagnosing a patient on their mental and social suitability. Daniel Rosenhand a professor of law and psychology at Stanford has decided to take the time and do research on how patients are diagnosed accurately. Although Rosenhand was aware the major social role psychiatrists have, he was determined to figure out if the patients are really insane as they were evaluated to be. Although ResenhandRead MoreHamlet Insane or Sane Essay783 Words   |  4 PagesHamlet- Sane or Insane In Shakespeares play Hamlet the main character Hamlet experiences many different and puzzling emotions. He toys with the idea of killing himself and then plays with the idea of murdering others. Many people ask themselves who or what is this man and what is going on inside his head. The most common question asked about him is whether or not he is sane or insane. Although the door seems to swing both ways many see him as a sane person with one thought on his mind,Read MoreBeing Sane And Insane Places1216 Words   |  5 Pages In the article On Being Sane in Insane Places, the problem is trying to figure out if sane people can be distinguished from the insane and what is or is not normal. This article talks about an experiment that was done to see if sane people were detected from the insane or not and how it was conducted. It states that â€Å"normality is distinct enough that it can be recognized wherever it occurs, for it is carried within a person.† This article will prove if this theory is correct or not and howRead MoreInsane Or Sane By Lauren Slater1266 Words   |  6 PagesInsane or Sane While reading the story Opening Skinners Box wrote by Lauren Slater there was a chapter that made me look at the world like I do and how sometimes the world relates to a story. The chapter was On Being Sane in Insane Places† while reading this chapter I seen and I was thinking that some of the things being said in the book was true. Sometimes people make wrong choices and they chose paths that lead them to bad consequence. Then we have those people that are born with this, bad consequencesRead Moreâ€Å"On Being Sane in Insane Places† Essay763 Words   |  4 Pagesï » ¿Ã¢â‚¬Å"On Being Sane in Insane Places† It was very interesting to read about Rosenhans study and how psychiatrists, who go through big coursework and training, could wrongly classify a patient. It surprised me how some psychiatrists couldn’t say they don’t know what’s wrong with patients instead they could possibly diagnose someone as insane. Though reading this chapter I found the strange things from Rosenhan’s study that was hard to believe. Slater states, â€Å"The strange thing was, the other patientsRead MoreArticle Review : On Being Sane Insane Places 952 Words   |  4 PagesThe article â€Å"On Being Sane in Insane Places† by D.L. Rosenhan was first published in Science in 1973. Rosenhan was a professor at Stanford University and this article is about one of his most famous experiments. The article is about the curiosities Rosenhan had in regards to sanity. He wanted to know if there was any valid way of determining if a person was actually â€Å"insane† and if sanity was real. The experiment he devised included himself as one of eight pseudopatients, as he puts it, who malingeredRead MoreBilly Pilgrim: Sane or Insane? Essay1144 Words   |  5 Pagesand morbid events differently than others. Billy accepts a way of life that is not perceivable to other humans. Many would argue that Billy ’s experiences make him insane, but Billy’s experiences with the Tralfamadorians actually allows him to preserve his sanity, and stay a very intelligent man. Many argue that Billy is completely insane. Their position may include the fact that Billy never mentioned the planet Tralfamadore before he got into the plane crash. This is a great point because an eventRead MoreAnalysis Of Emily Dickinson s Poem, The Insane And The Sane976 Words   |  4 Pagesvaluable. Thus, imagination and enjoyment should not be constrained by the stigma of having a different worldview. Moreover, it uses metaphors to connect both world: the insane and the sane. The opening, â€Å"We Grow accustomed to the Dark.† In this, I found a sense of friendliness with the mentally ill. It uses â€Å"dark† as a metaphor for the insane to contrast with the light which is sanity. In other words, Dickinson, creates a contrast between two scenarios: one that I will call sun and the other moon. TheyRead MoreCritical Evaluation of Rosenhans Study on Being Sane in Insane Places1571 Words   |  7 PagesThe question of what it means to be labelled ‘psychologically abnormal’ is examined closely in Rosenhans study of ‘On Being Sane in Insane Places’. This study highlights the usefulness and consequences of being diagnostically labelled. Rosenhans study ‘On Being Sane in Insane Places’ tests the hypothesis that ‘We cannot distinguish the sane from the insane in psychiatric hospitals’. (Rosenhan, 1973) This study is an influential criticism in testing the validity of psychiatric diagnoses, contextualRead MoreWhy Sane Individuals Can Be Distinguished From Insane Individuals1340 Words   |  6 PagesAccording to Ronson and Rosenhan, there is a question of whether sane individuals can be distinguished from insane individuals. They suggest that psychotherapists are too quick to label someone with a psychiatric disorder and in numerous cases they miss the mark. An inaccurate diagnosis of a mental disorder may cause a person to receive treatment they do not need, and possibly not receive the treatment that they do need. This causes countless problems for the patient, including difficulty acquiring